Post History

Source: https://writers.stackexchange.com/a/34707
License name: CC BY-SA 3.0
License URL: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/

> So, the question is, how reliable is the advice: If the reader doesn't need it, cut it. If the scene doesn't progress **_the plot_** , cut it.[emphasis added]

I think you are conflating "needed" with "related to the plot." Here's some examples of material that may be critical to a story but not directly plot-related.

- It may relate to an important **sub-plot** , e.g. progressing the story of Kenobi passing knowledge to Skywalker.

- It may relate to critical **character development** , e.g. the setup of Solo as an mercenary whose personal story (his progression to pro bono heroism) must resolve for the main plot to resolve.

- It may act as **setup for a callback** later, e.g. the setup of Solo as an atheist would later be called back when he bid Leia "May the Force be with you" during an emotional goodbye.

- It may be part of **greater narrative** , e.g. the longstanding relationship among wookie and droids, which spans many of the films.

- It may serve as **setup for the next scene,** e.g. morphing levity into forboding as the protogonists approach a particularly dangerous area.

- It may serve a **specific marketing purpose** , e.g. if a stakeholder in the production hoped to merchandise themed chess sets.

Original score: 5