How to write a vulnerable moment without it seeming cliche or mushy?

Switch the bravery. For this scene, her love interest is the brave one. As always, create a conflict between them. First draft of a long example:

Marcie heard something, a gasp, and moved to the back of the house. She heard it again, from Lexi's room, and moved to the door. Crying. Muffled crying. It sounded like Lexi. Was she crying? She thought she should walk away, respect her privacy, but the thought of Lexi actually crying was too much. She opened the door and walked in.

Lexi jumped, wiping her eyes. "Get out. Get out of here!"

"You're crying. What happened?"

Lexi wouldn't meet her eyes, she turned her head to the side. "Nothing."

"No, something." Marcie took a slow step toward her.

Lexi stood and faced her, eyes red, then strode to meet her. She raised her voice. "I said, get out!"

Her fists were clenched. She was angry. Marcie felt herself flush, she almost turned and ran, but stood her ground. Her knees felt weak. Her voice trembled. "I won't. You don't cry. So something's really wrong, Lexi. Tell me what's wrong."

Lexi's expression changed, from anger to ... is it sorrow?

"I'm sorry," Lexi said. "I shouldn't scare you." She turned back and sat on the bed, then fell face first into the pillow. She didn't say anything else.

Marcie hesitated, then moved to sit on the bed beside her, and put her hand on Lexi's shoulder, which made Lexi twitch. "Tell me."

Lexi's voice was muffled through the pillow. "I'm afraid. I have to fight Petrovski, and I think he might kill me."

Petrovski. Holy shit. "Wow. That's a really good reason."

Marcie was silent, thinking. Lexi sat up, and looked at her, half amused. "You think so?"

Marcie's hand had fallen to her lap. "Well. I would cry."

Lexi sniffed. "You cry if you spill coffee on yourself."

"Coffee stains, and that was my favorite dress!"

Lexi nodded, and leaned left to gently bump into Marcie, then looked away toward the window. "I know. What do you do when you're afraid?"

Then, however her love interest comforts her, proceed.

posted over 5 years ago

CC BY-SA 4.0

Amadeus‭

3166 reputation 2 1399 614 37

There is a trick for this in The Emotional Craft of Fiction.

It's called 'me centered narration.'

Essentially, you have the character express at length in narrative (protest too much) what she wants everyone to think about her, in this case the opposite attribute of what she is actually feeling.

He came into my room and I quickly wiped my eyes, before he could see my tears. I refused to show any vulnerability, I was nothing like the girls in town, who constantly needed help for the least little thing. That wasn't me.

"What's wrong" he asked gently.

"Nothing." I busied myself about the room, not looking at him, afraid that doing so would lead me to another melt down. Where had that come from? I wasn't a frail little girl who needed saving. I'd saved myself long ago--knew plenty well how to stay ahead of trouble.

...etc...

"All right," he said at last, "I'm glad you're okay."

He made to leave, and I said, "No, wait."

Of course if you did something like this it'd be in your style, which this isn't. I think what it might do for your case is to keep the screaming hordes from saying your girl character is acting out of character. Instead, the scene serves to deepen her character and show that she has inner conflict.

posted over 5 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

DPT‭

660 reputation 40 73 114 0

I think it depends on the build up whether it seems fake. The character shouldn't just jump to tears. They should go through the whole grief cycle. This should happen even maybe in the span of a single conversation to show how upset she is.

She should seem put off but hopeful she can change it or something isn't real. Then she should be stand offish but depressed as she comes to understand something isn't working out or isn't changing. Then she should be angry at the world or something in particular, potentially irrationally angry even at the person that eventually comforts her. How could he understand what she is going through?! Then finally she should break and the tears should flow. As the tears flow, despite being attacked, he pulls her close to his chest. He may not understand what she is angry about, but he understands her.

Have some build up showing this is brewing a bit before it suddenly unravels, or do each stage longer and over several days. Just depends on how you want this scene to exactly play out.

posted over 5 years ago

CC BY-SA 3.0

user2927848‭

5 reputation 0 1 1 0